TastyTrade vs. TD Ameritrade Comparison

This comparison guide aids customers that battle to choose between TastyTrade and TD Ameritrade to locate the most effective online broker for their trading and investment demands. It examines the main features of the two brokers alongside to assist customers contrast their service and make an informed choice.

To aid customers pick the appropriate broker in between TastyTrade and TD Ameritrade to find the best-suited system, listed below is a checklist of broker’s benefits and drawbacks, adhered to by a comparison of their primary trading functions, including trading systems & tools, costs, mobile trading, down payment & withdrawal, properties, law, and consumer assistance.

TastyTrade vs. TD Ameritrade: Summary

tastytrade-logo

TastyTrade (previously TastyWorks) is a US based stock and options broker. It is regulated by two tier-one regulators (FINRA and SEC) and is therefore considered safe. The broker offers access to a wide range of options, futures and stocks.

TastyTrade’s platform offers various trading tools and features, intuitive charting apps and the TastyTrade content network. These features make tastytrade a great fit for experienced and active traders focusing on trading with futures and options. Although TastyTrade offers great educational materials and research tools, the platform can be overwhelming for beginners.

The minimum deposit at TastyTrade is $0. Customer support is responsive and well educated.

TD Ameritrade logo

TD Ameritrade is a US based online stock broker founded in 1975. It is regulated by two of the most strict US regulators the SEC and FINRA. The broker offers access to a wide range of stocks and forex pairs and a handful of bonds, options, futures, crypto, and other financial instruments.

TD Ameritrade has a proprietary trading platform (thinkorswim) and two mobile trading apps. Both have an intuitive design and feature a great set of trading tools and features.

TD Ameritrade has low trading fees compared to other similar brokers like tastytrade, Robinhood and Fidelity. They charge 0% commission on stocks and ETFs, while futures trading comes with high fees. Forex, options and bonds are available at average fees.

TD Ameritrade’s customer support is available by phone and email from 8:30 AM to 5:30 PM ET, Monday – Friday.

Pros

  • Low minimum deposit ($0)
  • Wide range of futures and options
  • Low, variable, and capped trading fees
  • Broad range of tools for advanced options and futures traders
  • Great research and educational materials

Cons

  • No fractional shares available
  • Limited instruments compared to other brokers
  • High margin rates required

Pros

  • Low minimum deposit ($0)
  • Free stock and ETF trading
  • Feature-rich desktop and web trading platform (thinkorswim)
  • Advanced charting capabilities and real-time data
  • Wide range of stocks and ETFs
  • Excellent mobile trading apps for casual and active traders

Cons

  • Mostly US markets and assets
  • Only accept bank wire transfers
  • Doesn’t offer fractional shares

Key features

  • Access to thousands of stocks, ETFs, futures, options on futures, commodities, and cryptocurrencies
  • Advanced trading tools and dynamic charting features (custom indicators, watch lists, and curve analysis)
  • Multiple advanced order types available (good until canceled and good until date)
  • Free monthly portfolio analysis
  • Support for Expert Advisors and other automated trading software

Key features

  • Wide range of US stocks and ETFs
  • Vast selection of charting tools and indicators
  • Daily market analysis in the form webinars, webcasts, and podcasts
  • 0% commission stock and ETF trading
  • Access to IPOs, annuities, fixed income products, and lending programs

TastyTrade vs. TD Ameritrade Comparison

Select up to 3 Brokers

24Option
ActivTrades
Admiral Markets
ADSS
Ally Invest
Alpaca Markets
Alpari
Alvexo
Amana Capital
AMP Futures
AMP Global
ARMO Broker
AVAtrade
Axi
Axiory
Ayrex
Binary.com
BinaryCent
Binomo
BlackBull Markets
Brokerpoint
Capex (Ex. CFD Global)
Capital.com
Capitalize.ai
Captrader
Charles Schwab
ChoiceTrade
City Index
CMC Markets
Comdirect
Davy Select
Degiro
Dukascopy
E-Trade
EasyEquities
Eightcap
eOption
eToro
ETX Capital
ExpertOption
FBS
Fidelity
FinmaxFX
Finq.com
Firstrade
Flatex
Forex.com
FP Markets
Fusion Markets
FX Trading
FXCM
FXPro
FXTM
GoMarkets
HF Markets
HYCM
IC Markets
IG Trading
Interactive Brokers
Internaxx
IQ Option
IQCent
IronFX
Libertex Review March 2024
Lightspeed
LiteFinance
Magnifi
Markets.com
Merrill Edge
MEXEM
Moneta Markets
Multibank
Naga
Next Markets
Ninja Trader
Oanda
OctaFX
Olymp Trade
OneRoyal
Optimus Futures
OptionRobot.com
Passfolio
Pepperstone
Plus500
Pocket Option
Questrade
RaceOption
Rakuten Securities
Revolut
Robinhood
RoboForex
Sarwa
Saxo Bank
Skilling
SogoTrade
Spreadex
Swissquote
Tastytrade
TD Ameritrade
ThinkMarkets
Tickmill
TMGM
Toroption
Trade Ideas
Trade Nation
TradeStation
Trading212
TrendSpider
Vantage
Vestinda
VT Markets
Webull
XM
XTB
Zacks Trade
Zerodha
Compare brokers

BROKER COMPARISON

tastytrade-logo
TD Ameritrade logo

Overall rating

4,1/5

4,1/5

Overall rating

4,1/5

4,1/5

Trading Platform & Tools

4.1

4.4

See details
Automated Trading
Charting Tools
Conditional Orders
cTrader
Demo Account
Desktop Platform
Max Leverage 5:1 1:2
MetaTrader 4 (MT4)
MetaTrader 5 (MT5)
Mobile Version
Mutual Fund Management
Proprietary Platform
Social/Copy Trading
Trading Alerts
Trading signals
Watchlist
Web Version

Fees

4.2

3.6

See details
Withdrawal Fee 0 0
Deposit Fee 0 0
Inactivity Fee 0 0
Cost Per Trade 0 0
Cost Per Month 0 0
Forex (EUR/USD) 0 1.3 pips
Stocks & ETF 0 $6.95
CFD (Gold) 0 0
Crypto 1% open 1% close (max $10 each way) 0
Options $1 per contract 0.65 per options contract fee
Conversion Fees 0 $75 transfer fee
Misc. Fees 0 0
Overnight Fees 0 0

Mobile Trading

5.0

5.0

See details
Android
Apple
Watchlist
Econ. Calendar
Charting Tools

Deposit & Withdrawal

3.0

1.9

See details
Minimum deposit (in UAE) 0 0
Bank Wire
Credit/Debit Card
Cash
Check
Islamic Account Transfer
E-payments
Paypal
Skrill
Neteller

Assets

4.0

4.9

See details
Shares 2400 3700
ETF & Funds 0 13000
Crypto 25 0
Commodities 0 10
Indices 7 12
Options 0 0
Futures 83 70
Bonds 0 40000
Forex Instruments 0 70
CFD Indices & Funds 0 0
CFD Stocks 0 0
CFD Commodities 0 0
CFD Crypto 0 0
CFD Bonds 0 0
Binary Options 0 0
SWAPS 0 0
Saving Plans 0 0

Regulation

5.0

5.0

See details
Tier 1 License
Tier 2 License
Tier 3 License

Research & Education

3.5

4.3

See details
Webinars
Educational Resources
Daily News Updates
Market Indepth Analysis
Pers. Training & Room
Market Research

Customer Support

4.0

4.0

See details
Email
Phone
Live Chat
24/7 support
Multilingual Spanish English / Spanish
Personal Account Manager

Winner

TastyTrade vs. TD Ameritrade Comparison Conclusion

The results of our comparison of TastyTrade vs. TD Ameritrade are wrapped up in the table below.

Broker:Best For:
TastyTradeOptions Trading
TD AmeritradeUS Stocks and ETFs

Picking the appropriate selection in between TastyTrade and TD Ameritrade can be difficult. Both on-line brokers have similarities however vary pertaining to trading instruments, platforms & apps, law, down payment & withdrawals, and study and education. Selecting the best broker depends on users’ trading & financial investment objectives, individual choices, and experience level.

To make a better-informed decision, users can read our detailed broker reviews, comparison or use our broker selector to help them find the ideal broker.

This site is registered on wpml.org as a development site.